Today’s news:

CB13 votes unanimously for Z Best Car Wash variance

Z Best buddies

Brooklyn Daily

They’re Z Best!

The embattled Z Best Car Wash enjoyed overwhelming support from Community Board 13 Wednesday night, when the panel voted unanimously to approve the business’s latest variance hoop they’ve been forced to jump through by the city, despite protests from state Assemblyman Steve Cymbrowitz’s representative who asked the board to vote against the business.

“It is a travesty and embarrassment that the Department of Building’s has acted this way, and I think it’s a travesty that the politicians can’t speak the same language — that you have a politician that strongly supports this business and a politician that’s strongly against it,” said board member and architect Jack Suben. “I think it’s a shame that everybody has to come to this body just to speak with each other.”

Z Best had purchased the property on Coney Island Avenue between Avenues Y and Z, which had been a car wash since the 1950s, and received all the necessary permits to begin work there, according to attorney Eric Palatnik, who represents Z Best as they navigate the Board of Standards and Appeals’s tricky variance process. Permits in hand, the owners began a $1 million retrofit of the aging facilities to modernize the building and equipment.

But later the Department of Buildings began receiving a furious stream of complaints from nearby residents and Assemblyman Cymbrowitz’s office grumbling about the car wash’s noisy machinery. As a result, the business was audited not once, not twice, but three times before the city found enough evidence to revoke the permits it had already issued to the new owners before they sunk their life savings into the renovation.

“The job got audited, and the Department of Buildings went through their paperwork line by line to discredit their prior approvals,” said Palatnik, speaking before Community Board 13. “Everything past muster twice, and before a third review the job was allowed to continue, resulting in hundreds of thousands being invested in the property.”

By that point, however, Z Best had finished almost all of the work necessary to get their car wash operation up and running, which they did successfully for almost a year, before they were issued a padlock order from the Department of Buildings on the grounds that a zoning variance granted to the previous business was void. The city claimed — using pictures from Google Maps as evidence — that Z Best had not operated as a car wash for longer than two years, thus requiring Z Best to seek a new variance through the Board of Standards and Appeals.

Residents living nearby Z Best have complained about several issues regarding the car wash, including a gate which occasionally opens onto the adjoining Gerald Court to allow traffic from the Coney Island Avenue business onto the residential street, although owner Russell Shern says that exit is only used under special circumstances and that Z Best had hired a employee to direct traffic shortly before they were shut down.

The main concern among neighbors, however, has always been the car wash’s noisy machinery, a cause Assemblyman Cymbrowitz frequently cites as his motivation for his crusade against the business.

“The noise is by far the largest and most shared of concerns,” said Ilya Novofastovsky, speaking before Community Board 13 on behalf of the assemblyman.

But the meeting was attended by neighbors of the business, including Andy Mitchell, who lives in the house directly beside Z Best, and he lauded the car wash’s efforts to mitigate the noise. Mitchell said he was not in favor of destroying the owners’ investment.

“I’m going to be honest, they did reduce the noise level,” said Mitchell. “I’m not looking to close any business. I realize they invested a lot of money and, compared to the old car wash, their building is beautiful.”

Furthermore, as a condition of the board’s support, Shern agreed, in writing, to install a canopy that would reduce the noise level even further — although that would require the Department of Buildings to lift the stop-work order.

“From day one we wanted to eliminate the noise 100 percent,” said Shern. “In order to do that we wanted to enclose our machines in a canopy, but because of a stop-work order, we’re unable to do that.”

The business’s written commitment was not enough for Cymbrowitz’s representative.

“A yes [vote] means you’re getting carte blanche to make the promises you’re making, without holding you to them,” said Novofastovsky.

That promise was, however, enough for the community board, which gave Z Best their unanimous approval.

Reach reporter Colin Mixson at cmixson@cnglocal.com or by calling (718) 260-4514.

Pin It
Print this story Permalink

Reader Feedback

Ross from SheepsheadBay says:
Kudos to Councilman Nelson for supporting small businesses at the same time improving the quality of life if its neighbors.
March 11, 2013, 12:47 pm
Russell AKA Ross from SheepsheadBay says:
BSA will look at the fake documents they gave the Buildings Department.

They gave fake documentation to Buildings Department claiming the car wash was never closed.

They have no WATER USAGE not paid any SALES TAX and more.

Car wash with no water bills?
Car Wash showing $0 on tax returns?
Car wash claiming that they never closed, but paid no sales tax or any taxes?

Too bad that DOB didn't call the FBI on them.
March 12, 2013, 12:04 pm
321 from sheepshead bay says:
Reply to Russell AKA Ross from SheepsheadBay:

I can understand who u would know about water bills.
Tax return information, on the other hand is not private info. So there could be only two reasons for u to say this. One is, you work for a government agency and abusing your position. Second, you do not know what you are talking about. There could be third, you are working for one of the people who has access to this information. In either case i have one question. what is it that you have against these owners and their carwash. They will fix the noise and all other problems that one might have. I was told that they would fix the noise a long time ago if people like you would let them do it and the dob lift the work stop order. are you getting paid to stay home and monitor these blogs. I think the real question is who are you getting paid from.
March 12, 2013, 1:21 pm
Justice is served from Sheepshead Bay says:
To Russell AKA Ross from SheepsheadBay:

Firstly, you do not need to repeat the same thing twice... We get it your a smart ass and for that matter not very bright either! Secondly, how do you know the documentation submitted was fake? How did you gain access to these documents submitted? Please, stand behind your words and intrigue us with your facts! Thirdly, the better question here is; how is it that you know such confidential details? Really tax records?!?! I wonder who you working with or maybe better said who you working for! Prior to making such statements As " Too bad that DOB didn't call the FBI on them". It takes a Moron to make such a statement, hen we all know DOB is on a city level and at most what is the relevance between DOB and FBI??

Sometimes one begs the question; why do people need to make issues of something that is nonsensical! It's a business that wants to operate and generate jobs!

There the best carwash in the area!!! Re-open them up already!!!!!
March 12, 2013, 4:01 pm

Enter your comment below

By submitting this comment, you agree to the following terms:

You agree that you, and not BrooklynDaily.com or its affiliates, are fully responsible for the content that you post. You agree not to post any abusive, obscene, vulgar, slanderous, hateful, threatening or sexually-oriented material or any material that may violate applicable law; doing so may lead to the removal of your post and to your being permanently banned from posting to the site. You grant to BrooklynDaily.com the royalty-free, irrevocable, perpetual and fully sublicensable license to use, reproduce, modify, adapt, publish, translate, create derivative works from, distribute, perform and display such content in whole or in part world-wide and to incorporate it in other works in any form, media or technology now known or later developed.

CNG: Community Newspaper Group